On My Watch

Monday, February 05, 2007

Was Steve Jobs right?

Was he right when he dissed Java recently (setting the Java world aflutter)?

Well noone wants to bet against the Legend himself, certainly not a mere mortal like me with far fewer 0 (zero)'s in my bank account (and far fewer bank accounts I am sure), but, let me raise some ahem points:

  1. What are you going to do with all those existing Java applications? We still have Fortran and Cobol.

  2. Why (back to this century) isn't there room for more than 1 "rich client" technology in the browser, phones and end user devices in general? iPhone may support Javascript but can one technology be the be all and end all? (I don't care how cool - or is it hot - Ajax/JS is. It is NOT easy to build robust complex apps in. Things that are easy in Java - like avoiding name space collisions to take a simple example - is too hard in Javascript. And things that are hard in Java - like building a ui table that handles 100,000 rows - is virtually impossible in Ajax.) . Maybe a phone doesn't need to support high performance applications (yet!), but does it make sense to limit client technologies to the flavor of the month? I think not.

  3. Wouldn't it be better to assume there will multiple client technologies? (Ajax - XML/HttpRequest this year but what about next or the next 2? ) There are too many devices. (Heck even Apple might come up with a better rendering technology for cell phones.) So Java vs Ajax vs html/dhtml vs Flex is the wrong question. Wouldn't it be better to plan for multiple uses, faces or skins for an application or for multiple client technologies? Wouldn't it be better to code the UI or at least the user interactions and page flows independent of the client technology du jour and plan for both change as well as innovation? The reality of multi-faceted, dynamic and truly reusable/extensible applications is here - or at least the potential for it is.
And all these changes or lack of easy change cost - in real costs, in time, in opportunities lost.

And, unlike Steve, I can't afford to waste any of my 0's.

Labels: ,


Post a Comment

Links to this post:

Create a Link

<< Home